Condo Details
Cashelmara Condos at a Glance
Location: Bay Village, Ohio
Building type: Lakefront condominiums
Year built: 1982–1985
Unit sizes: 1,281–3,640 sq ft
Bedrooms: 1–4
Recent sales (Oct 2023–Oct 2026): $262K–$800K (17 sales)
Reported condo fee: $792–$1,368/mo
Condo sales, last 10 years: 40
Sales and community data: MLS Now, closed condo sales Oct 2016–Oct 2026. Fees as reported in listings; confirm with the association.
Buying or selling at Cashelmara Condos? Call (216) 916-7778 · Condo financing: Matt Sheffey, Condo Financing Specialist, (440) 668-2942 · Title & closing: Trilogy Title Agency
Cashelmara Condos: historic character, modern comfort, and lake views
Cashelmara Condos set elegant, renovated homes inside a cherished Bay Village mansion on the Lake Erie shoreline. Many residences enjoy sunrise and sunset vistas, while layouts remain unique from unit to unit. Even so, shared amenities make life easy: heated garage parking, ample guest spaces, an indoor pool, landscaped green space, and inviting community rooms. Inside, floor-to-ceiling windows rise toward 10-foot ceilings for natural light throughout the day; moreover, generous closets and storage keep spaces tidy. Many homes add private balconies, and bathrooms often feature walk-in closets, oversized soaking tubs, and separate double shower stalls. Options typically range from one to three bedrooms, depending on availability.
Location & everyday convenience—parks, arts, shopping, schools, and care
Fresh air is steps away along the lakefront; for bigger green spaces, head to Huntington Reservation for beach sunsets and paved paths, then drop into the Lake Erie Nature & Science Center and nearby BAYarts for classes and galleries. Prefer a central park? Stroll Cahoon Memorial Park. For bigger outings, browse 150+ shops and restaurants at Crocker Park in Westlake; meanwhile, readers can visit the Bay Village Branch Library. Families may review academics through Bay Village Schools, and care stays close at UH St. John Medical Center. With quick connections to Lake Road and I-90, errands and commutes remain simple.
Why Cashelmara Condos work for today’s buyers
Choose Cashelmara Condos if you want historic architecture married to low-maintenance living and real amenities. The setting is quiet yet central, so daily needs, parks, arts, and healthcare are minutes away. Consequently, first-time buyers, right-sizers, and lake lovers all find an easy rhythm here. In short, Cashelmara blends character, comfort, and a true Lake Erie lifestyle in one of Greater Cleveland’s most desirable suburbs.
Featured Listing:
23200 Lake Rd # 53 , Bay Village, OH 44140
2 Bed | 3.5 Bath | 3771 sqft | $690,000
The moment you walk in to the crowned jewel of Cashelmara, you realize that this one of a kind spectacular two story condo has the greatest lake views in the area, with 2 stories of windows. The gracious living room opens the kitchen, dining room and den. The large master suite is complete with a cozy fireplace, twin walk-in closets, a master bath with separate shower, tub and a laundry area. The second floor has even more amenities. An ample second bedroom has a full ensuite bath, a walk-in closet, and stunning views. A built in office loft opens to the living area with amazing sunset views. A third full bath and a storage area with a temperature controlled wine room rounds out the floor. A 2 car garage and storage area completes the home. Add in the amenities of living in the Cashelmara Mansion, and this home has more to offer than any condo in the area. Contact our My Cleveland Condo Team today to schedule a private showing!
Back to Bay Village Condos for Sale
Frequently Asked Questions
What do condos at Cashelmara Condos sell for?
Based on MLS Now closed sales, most of the 17 condos that sold at Cashelmara Condos between October 2023 and October 2026 closed between $262K and $800K. Prices depend on floor plan, floor, view and updates. For current listings or a value estimate on a specific unit, call the My Cleveland Condo team at (216) 916-7778.
What are the condo fees at Cashelmara Condos?
Recent MLS listings at Cashelmara Condos report condo fees of about $792 to $1,368 a month (sales from 2024 to 2026). What the fee covers, such as exterior maintenance, common-area insurance, water, heat or amenities, varies by association, so review the current budget, reserves and bylaws before you buy.
When was Cashelmara Condos built, and how big are the units?
Cashelmara Condos is a community of lakefront condominiums in Bay Village, Ohio, built between 1982 and 1985. Units that sold in the last 10 years ranged from about 1,281 to 3,640 square feet, with 1 to 4 bedrooms.
How often do condos at Cashelmara Condos come up for sale?
40 condos at Cashelmara Condos sold through the MLS between October 2016 and October 2026, about 4 a year on average. Our free Condo Finder can alert you when a unit comes up for sale.
Can I get a mortgage for a condo at Cashelmara Condos?
Yes, but condo loans depend on the association as well as the buyer. Lenders review owner-occupancy, reserves, insurance and any pending litigation, and FHA or VA loans require the project to be approved. Matt Sheffey of Keller Home Loans (NMLS #197990), our team's condo financing partner, can check Cashelmara Condos and get you pre-approved: (440) 668-2942. Trilogy Title Agency in Westlake can handle title and closing. You're always free to choose your own lender and title company.